Over at Dangerous Idea, the only reasonable counterargument was that the spaces of reductionist physical worlds and of god-created worlds are both infinite space, and that, as a result, we couldn't compare them. (There were plenty of unreasonable counterarguments, but I won't go into them here.)
So, to revise my argument, I'll consider something quite specific to our own universe. Consider the following spaces:
- The space of designed life-bearing worlds that have the physics of our universe.
- The space of non-designed life-bearing worlds that have the physics of our universe.